Page 11 - EMCAPP-Journal No. 24
P. 11
cries for help, moral suffering can o�en remain sense of self and responsibility. They may say
silent and secret. It then works within, contami- things like, “I failed the people who ma�ered
na�ng hearts and minds, all while remaining most to me” (a statement of guilt and self-bla-
unseen. Therapists can contribute by avoiding me), “I never thought I could do something like
the language of moral viola�on. Therapists are that” (shock at viola�ng one’s moral iden�ty),
o�en uneasy with moral language as it can feel “It feels like the ground has been ripped out
too closely associated with judgment, too from underneath me” (a loss of stability and
entangled with religion or philosophy, insuffi- trust in the world), or “I know I couldn’t stop
ciently scien�fic, or ethically risky. Similarly, what happened, but I s�ll feel like I should have
moral perspec�ves on suffering do not fit neat- been able to do something” (a painful struggle
ly into medical defini�ons or diagnos�c catego- between ra�onal awareness and lingering self-
ries, and they do not facilitate insurance reim- condemna�on from powerlessness). Entangled
bursement. This also reflects a clinical culture in shame, shock, complicity, self-hatred, and
that tends to explain behavior in terms of biolo- anger, this pain o�en stagnates within. Without
gy or environment, with less emphasis on hu- a framework to name or make sense of it, mo-
man agency, the role of the will, or personal re- ral suffering frequently stays hidden—unspo-
sponsibility. Instead of naming and working ken, unprocessed, and unresolved—even
with moral rupture, treatment tends to focus though its wounds cut just as deeply as those in
on resul�ng surface-level symptoms. post-trauma�c stress disorder (PTSD). Unlike
In contrast, clients commonly frame their suffe- PTSD, which is rooted mainly in autonomic fear
ring and pain using terms like guilt, betrayal, fai- reac�ons, moral injury wounds the conscience
lure, or wrongdoing, which are unmistakably and disrupts one’s sense of iden�ty, o�en lea-
moral in nature. Avoiding this language in clini- ving individuals disoriented, burdened by sha-
cal care risks mu�ng a client's deepest pain. me, and struggling with feelings of worthless-
Moral language gives expression to the voice of ness (Litz et al., 2009). To highlight the dis�nc�-
conscience, naming injuries to trust and integri- on, the following vigne�es illustrate the core
ty that cannot be fully conveyed by symptoms features and differences between a typical
alone. Far from adding shame through judg- PTSD response and a moral harm response.
ment, acknowledging moral weight can actually
bring relief, affirming that moral struggle is a Maria and her two young children were trap-
profoundly human experience. Healing moral ped on the roof of their home as the waters
injury requires more than symptom relief—it rose during a devasta�ng flood. She and her
calls for meaning making, restora�on, and mo- children managed to scramble to the roof. For
ral repair. Used with humility and ethics, moral hours, she hung on to her children and the
language can be used without imposing values. chimney �ghtly, terrified the waters would
Using the moral language of our clients can sweep them away from her before help arrived.
open space for greater honesty, responsibility, When a rescue team finally pulled them to
and hope. This is why theologically and spiritu- safety, her body shook with relief, but the fear
ally integrated care or interprofessional colla- never le� her. Weeks later, Maria was incredib-
bora�on is so vital when addressing a client’s ly distressed when she heard the sound of rain,
moral suffering. avoided driving near rivers, and woke up screa-
ming from nightmares of her children being
Differen�a�ng Moral Harm from Trauma pulled from her and drowning. She couldn’t
When experiences of moral harm surface in stop reliving the sense of helpless terror she ex-
therapy, they extend beyond the typical sym- perienced on that roof.
ptom complaints we see with most clinical con- No�ce that in this case, the wound is likely
di�ons. What emerges are soul-deep laments PTSD, due to the characteris�c symptoms that
of rupture, disillusionment, regret, and loss. Cli- were encoded through fear and rooted in the
ents o�en express moral suffering in deeply threat to her and her children’s lives. In con-
personal ways, not just recoun�ng what happe- trast, moral harm does not arise from fear
ned but also describing how it sha�ered their itself, but from the ac�ons we take, the wrongs
11
